You might not give it much thought, but the way bartenders combine their ingredients with spoons and shakers is a big deal. It’s more than just mixing – it’s about transforming separate parts into one delicious whole. Have you ever wondered why most cocktails are served ice-cold? It’s not just for refreshment; it’s a crucial part of the mixing process. As the ice melts, it does two important things: it chills the drink and dilutes the alcohol. This might seem unexpected, but the ice is actually doing you a favor! It softens the harsh taste of uncut liquor and helps all the ingredients bind together into a cohesive and more enjoyable drink. Getting the right amount of ice-cold water into your cocktail is what makes the difference between drinking two-plus shots of plain gin and sipping on a cool, classy martini with olives.
The goal of mixing your drink is simple: to add enough water content from the ice to balance the cocktail’s alcohol and other ingredients while simultaneously chilling it. Whether you shake, stir, blend, or even just throw your drink around a bit, the end result should be the same: a properly chilled and diluted beverage.
Your mixing method also impacts the amount of air that gets added to the drink. Shaking creates maximal aeration, while stirring only adds a minimal amount. This might seem like a minor detail, but it has a significant effect on your drink’s texture, which contributes to the overall mouthfeel and how the flavors are perceived. This texture difference can make a memorable cocktail versus a forgettable one.
While there are some general rules about which technique to employ (shaking for cloudy drinks, stirring for clear ones, and so on), it’s not uncommon for cocktail enthusiasts to shake their drinks when others might stir, and vice versa. Ever seen a fancy bartender shake a dry gin martini? Absolutely not. But the key takeaway here isn’t to memorize a list of dos and don’ts. It’s to understand the bottom line: there’s no single right way to shake or stir everything. The most important thing is to know why you’re doing it and how it affects your drink.
Contents
The Rule: When to Shake or Stir a Cocktail
So, when do you shake or stir a cocktail? Here’s the rule:
- Shake It: You’ll want to shake those cocktails that contain non-alcoholic ingredients, commonly things like citrus juice. A perfect example? The beloved Margarita – shaking gives it that brighter, refreshing taste, ideal for being consumed quickly.
- Stir It: On the other hand, you’ll want to stir those cocktails that primarily contain alcohol-based ingredients like spirits, vermouths, and liqueurs. Think of a classic Manhattan – that boozy, stronger, spirit-forward flavor is best when the drink is sipped slowly.
- Build It: But there’s a last category of drinks too – the built cocktails. These don’t need stirring as such because all the ingredients are mixed right in the glass. We’re talking scotch and sodas, gin and tonics, and champagne or sparkling wine cocktails. With these bubbly numbers, you don’t want to flatten the bubbles by shaking, so the far easiest way is to simply pour over ice and serve.
When to Shake Your Drink
As a general rule of thumb, if your cocktail contains citrus, egg, cream, or any other opaque ingredient, you’ll want to shake it. If your mix of ingredients is cloudy, vigorous shaking will ensure that everything combines thoroughly. Shaking alcoholic and nonalcoholic elements quickly chills the drink while also incorporating air. The end result is a light, frothy drink that’s uniform from the first sip to the last.
It’s worth noting that if you’re using egg whites, you’ll need a wet and dry shake (with and without ice) to properly emulsify the mix. This is because a significant amount of aeration and agitation is required to integrate these components and achieve a cohesive, pleasurable texture. A stirred margarita is not the same as a shaken one, and experiencing the difference that technique makes is a must first-hand.
In any case, your mixing method affects the rate at which your drink gets chilled and diluted. While getting it properly chilled is an important detail to consider, shaken drinks have a touch more vigor, rhythm, and an awareness of the state of the ice while shaking.
What Happens When You Shake
The central element that sets shaking apart is the way the ice is forcefully churned back and forth, producing multiple effects on the cocktail. It chills and dilutes the drink much faster than stirring due to the increased surface contact generated in those 8–10 seconds of shaking.
But shaking has a substantial influence on the cocktail’s texture, too. As the ice crashes around, it creates lots of tiny air bubbles, giving the drink a lively, aerated consistency. These effects are evident in the visible layer of froth on top of the drink.
There’s also a significant but less obvious impact – shaking completely blends all the flavors together. It’s not merely mixing the ingredients, but totally emulsifying and transfiguring them into a unified flavor profile that can’t be easily picked apart. It creates a genuinely different flavor experience than a stirred cocktail.
Additionally, the way shaking mixes the cocktail ingredients is different from stirring due to the contrasting forces involved. Things like eggs or heavier fruit purées are prime examples of ingredients that mix better with the vigorous action of shaking.
READ: How to Shake a Cocktail
When to Stir a Cocktail
If your cocktail’s main ingredients are liquor-based, they’re often better off being stirred. Classics like martinis and negronis get their biggest source of flavor from the booze itself, so you want to preserve that character by mixing it gently with ice. Stirring prevents over-diluting and keeps aeration to a minimum, resulting in a smooth, sipping texture with a lush, velvety mouthfeel that still has just the right amount of bite.
The key difference between shaking and stirring is that stirred cocktails get as little aeration as possible to yield that silky, semi-viscous elixir. These cocktails typically have ingredients that are clear and free of particles like citrus juices that would require shaking to properly integrate.
What Happens When You Stir
Stirring is the polar opposite of shaking – instead of violently agitating the ice, it’s gently pushed around to create as little disruption as possible. Naturally, this has an inverse effect to shaking when it comes to chilling and dilution – stirring chills and dilutes much more slowly. A typical stir takes 18–25 seconds, but critically, no aeration is created, so the texture of the drink remains unaffected – smooth, even and silky without being packed with air bubbles.
While stirring still thoroughly mixes the cocktail ingredients, it allows them to retain more of their distinctiveness, as opposed to shaking which repurposes them into a new, singular flavor. In stirred cocktails, you’ll find the components are more layered, with individual flavors sticking out a bit rather than being totally blended.
The Two Basic Styles of Cocktail: Shaken or Stirred
As we’ve examined, shaking and stirring affect a cocktail differently, so let’s recap the general rule for when to shake or stir a drink, and why each method works best.
Shaken Drinks
Shaking is better suited for drinks with fresh ingredients like cocktails that are lighter, citrusy and refreshing. They benefit from the vibrant, aerated texture that shaking provides, helping them go down easily. The propensity for these drinks to be consumed quicker also makes the added chill and dilution from shaking a good thing.
Stirred Drinks
Stirring is appropriate for alcohol-based cocktails featuring stronger, more pronounced spirits. It allows the spirit to be the star of the show with a smooth, silky texture that preserves the subtleties of the drink. With less dilution and no aeration, the result is a denser, more bracing cocktail – ideal for types that are meant to be sipped and savored slowly.
How Long to Shake Your Drink
As a general rule, you’ll want to shake your drink with ice until it’s well chilled and properly diluted. But, what does that mean in practice? The actual shaking time depends on a few factors:
- The ice: If you’re using wet ice that’s been sitting out and has slowly started to melt, or ice that is shaped irregularly like fine or crushed ice, you’ll need to shake vigorously for a shorter period of time – roughly 5 to 7 seconds. Proportionate and tempered clear ice made one by one in commercial machines in bars (think proper ice cubes) will require 7 to 12 seconds for maximum aeration and appropriate chill and dilution. A tempered two by two ice cube or something small and proportionate like that may need 12 to 15 seconds.
- Serving style: There’s a difference in how long a cocktail should be shaken if it’s served up (without ice) versus over ice. For a drink served up, you need to shake longer for full dilution, while a drink served over ice only needs a vigorous 5 to 7 seconds to aerate and chill, as it will continue to dilute in the glass. Remember, the drink will receive more water content as the ice melts in the course of drinking it.
- Shaker type: The most common shaker is the two-piece stainless steel tin shaker. To use it, you build the drink in the smaller tin, add ice, and then seal with the larger one at a slight angle. Then, you shake with the smaller tin facing you. In the case the shaker breaks apart mid-shake, it wasn’t properly sealed. This can happen, especially with new, not broken in shakers. In this case, hit it on the liquid contents side, as opposed to the guest side, and the etiquette is to not notice this in cocktail bars.
It might seem straightforward: just putting your ingredients and ice in the mixing tins and letting it rip will create an optimal shaken drink. But, as you can see, the details do matter.
How Long to Stir a Cocktail
As a general rule, when stirring with fresh wet ice that’s proportionately tempered and clear one-by-one cubes from commercial machines like at most bars, you’ll want to stir for 30 to 45 seconds to yield a properly balanced and chilled cocktail. Misshapen or broken ice cubes require less time to achieve the desired chill and dilution, so use your taste buds and go by eye – using a straw to take a sip mid-stir can help see if more dilution is needed for larger chunks of ice that may need a longer stir.
One key detail to keep in mind is whether the stirred cocktail is being served up in a stemmed glass like a Martini or down over fresh ice like a Negroni. Up cocktails benefit from the water content and dilution that a longer 45+ second stir provides, since the alcohol is being served without any additional ice melt. An under-stirred, under-diluted Negroni is much less desirable than one served over ice that can continue diluting over the course of your drinking session.
To build the perfectly stirred drink, use a mixing pint glass with a wider base to maximize the liquid’s contact with the ice. Add your ingredients to the glass and get stirring! Practice makes perfect with these mixing methods, so keep at it to dial in your technique. It gets easier and easier when making quality cocktails comes down to properly preparing them – the simple things are often the devil in the details.
What Kind of Shaker Should I Use
The two most popular shaker designs are the Boston shaker and the cobbler shaker. Boston shakers are just two tin cups – one tin, one glass – that get slammed together to create a seal. They’re incredibly lo-fi and simple to use, as well as simpler to clean. Cobbler shakers are those high-tech, bottle-shaped devices you might imagine when picturing a cocktail shaker – three parts with a cup, built-in strainer, and a cap to keep things from splattering when you shake.
Both styles function perfectly fine, with no real difference in the quality of the drinks they produce. Many bartenders prefer the simplicity of Boston shakers, since there are fewer pieces to keep up with and fewer nooks and crannies that need scrubbing after multiple shake rounds. Plus, you’ll likely need a separate strainer like a spring-loaded Hawthorne strainer anyway. But cobbler shakers have an ease of use factor going for them. Luckily, both styles are pretty nice and cheap these days.
READ: How to Hold a Martini Glass
How should I Serve my Cocktails?
Stirred cocktails, like an Old Fashioned, are typically mixed and served in the same glass over fresh ice. This creates a dynamic drinking experience where the first sip is punchy, but the last one is lighter to prevent over-diluting. Use large ice cubes when stirring and serving to ensure they melt slowly.
For cocktails that are shaken or stirred, they should be strained into a separate vessel for serving. Shaken drinks are often served “on the rocks”, meaning poured over fresh ice through a strainer to keep them chilly and refreshing – ideal for bright, vibrant drinks like margaritas and mai tais. Stirred spirits-forward cocktails like Negronis are classically served “up” or “straight up” without ice, strained into a stemmed coupe or martini glass.
Don’t be confused if you see a cocktail served in a tall, stemmed glass that seemingly defies convention – the stem simply lifts the cocktail off the bar surface. Shaken drinks like Cosmos and stirred drinks like Manhattans are commonly served this way in a glass that won’t make or break the integrity of the drink. The stem can help keep your hands from heating things up in the absence of ice, though your own martini glasses at home won’t end the world if you drink it faster.
As with most cooking “rules,” take these tips as suggestions, not gospel. The basics are important when making great cocktails, but feel free to riff, experiment and tweak recipes to make drinks as dreamy as you like, shaken or stirred. There’s always time to make another round!
Final Words
When do you shake or stir a drink? It all comes down to the ingredients and the style of cocktail you’re aiming for. If your drink features cloudy elements like juices, dairy, or eggs, shaking is the way to go for a well-integrated, frothy texture. Opt for stirring when crafting spirit-forward concoctions with clear ingredients to maintain their smooth, silky character.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Why do you shake some drinks and stir others?
The decision to shake or stir a cocktail depends on its ingredients and the desired outcome. Shaking is used for drinks with cloudy ingredients like citrus juices, dairy, or eggs, as it helps to thoroughly combine them and create a frothy texture. Stirring is preferred for cocktails made with clear spirits, where the goal is to maintain a smooth, silky texture and preserve the delicate flavors.
What are the 4 significant effects of shaking a cocktail?
- Chilling: Shaking rapidly cools the cocktail by increasing the contact between the liquid and ice.
- Dilution: The ice melts as it’s shaken, adding water to the cocktail and softening its alcoholic strength.
- Aeration: Shaking incorporates air bubbles, creating a lighter, frothier texture and potentially altering the flavor profile.
- Emulsification: The vigorous agitation helps to fully integrate ingredients that might otherwise separate, like oil and water in a Daiquiri.
How to shake a cocktail?
- Combine ingredients in a shaker with ice.
- Securely close the shaker and hold it with both hands.
- Shake vigorously for 8–15 seconds, depending on the ice and desired dilution.
- Strain the cocktail into a glass.
Do you shake or stir an old-fashioned?
An Old Fashioned is traditionally stirred. This is because it’s made with only spirit-based ingredients (whiskey, bitters, sugar), and stirring helps to maintain its smooth, velvety texture and preserve the complex flavors of the whiskey.
How many seconds should you shake a cocktail?
The ideal shaking time depends on the size and type of ice used, as well as the desired level of chill and dilution. Generally, 8–15 seconds is a good range. Start with a shorter time and taste the cocktail to see if it needs further shaking.
Which is better, stirred or shaken?
Neither method is inherently better; they simply create different results. Shaken cocktails are typically lighter, frothier, and more refreshing, while stirred cocktails are smoother, silkier, and more spirit-forward. The best method depends on the specific cocktail and your personal preference.
